Which Witch Is Witchiest?

This extra credit entry is for both Period 1 and Period 2 students.

Here are a some different versions of the three witches from various sources - film, stage, fine art, comic books, etc. You can click on each image to enlarge.

Henry Fuseli

Théodore Chassériau

film adaptation directed by Roman Polanski

Austin Shakespeare Company

Long Overdue Theater Company

Jon Haward

Dream Puppets production

film adaptation directed by Orsen Welles

unknown stage production

unknown

Richard Westall

So, which witch is which? Which is the creepiest? The lamest? Most interesting? Closest to Shakespeare's original intent? Most effective for a modern audience? Which version would you most like to see if you were viewing the play as a live stage production? Let me know what you think. Remember, we're looking for insight, not merely personal opinion. So be sure to answer: "Why?"